I was so bummed I couldn’t find swatches of all these shades, especially wanting to see them on someone’s skin. I ordered quite a few since they were steeply discounted, and it turns out the shades are so versatile! Most of the shades I purchased are very similar and the difference is barely visible on the skin.
SO, my first advice to you is to not overthink it and just buy whichever color description speaks to you. I can hardly tell the difference but here’s some descriptors.
Soul has no real shimmer so it’s a great base color for light and medium skin tones
Nude beach is a cool silvery sparkly base tone that works great on brow bone and inner corner
Queen Phyllis is the most shimmery of all, still in the same warm color family like soul
Bahamas is shimmery like nude beach and queen Phyllis but it has a pink hue that’s entirely versatile
Celestine isn’t as dark as I hoped it would, for my crease or accenting my liner. It’s a deep pewter but doesn’t go on dark at all. So again, great for the lid and some crease action but subtle depth with lots of shimmer.
Beautiful Autumn is the only distinctive one of all that I’ve purchased. It’s a beautiful reddish bronze like you’d expect. Medium pigment, easily blends.